Legal Guide

Can Passengers Sue Uber/Lyft Directly?

Ridesharing has made transportation convenient in Alberta—until an accident occurs. Then the question becomes: Can I sue the rideshare company directly, or do I have to go through their insurer?

The answer depends on the accident's circumstances and fault. Uber and Lyft rarely accept direct legal liability for driver negligence, but their commercial insurance policies offer significant protection for injured passengers.

As Alberta personal injury lawyers, we'll explain when passengers can sue the rideshare company, when insurance is sufficient, and how to ensure full compensation after a crash.

This guide covers:

When passengers can sue Uber or Lyft directly

How passengers are usually compensated

Common scenarios and who pays

Why suing rideshare companies directly is difficult

How a lawyer protects passenger rights

Steps to take after an Uber or Lyft accident

Understanding the Relationship Between Drivers and Rideshare Companies

Uber and Lyft classify drivers as independent contractors, not employees, meaning the company isn't automatically liable for a driver's negligence in most cases. Rideshare companies protect passengers through mandatory commercial insurance, which provides up to $2 million in third-party liability coverage during active trips.

In Short:

The driver is personally responsible for the accidentDrivers are independent contractors, not employees.

The rideshare insurer pays compensationCommercial insurance covers injuries during active trips.

Uber or Lyft only face direct lawsuits in rare casesOnly when corporate negligence is involved, not ordinary crashes.

When Passengers Can Sue Uber or Lyft Directly

While most claims go through insurance, direct lawsuits against Uber or Lyft are possible in certain situations. These cases are complex and rare, but when corporate negligence contributes to the accident, Uber or Lyft can be sued like any other company.

Negligent hiring or screening

If the company failed to properly vet a dangerous driver with prior offences.

Failure to maintain adequate insurance

If the commercial policy was inactive or insufficient.

Defective app design or unsafe practices

If distracted app notifications contributed to the crash.

Breach of duty to passengers

For example, failing to ensure driver background checks or vehicle inspections.

Key point: Direct lawsuits against rideshare companies are rare and require proof of corporate negligence, not just driver error.

How Passengers Are Usually Compensated

In most Alberta rideshare accidents, passengers don't need to sue Uber or Lyft directly. Compensation typically comes from: 1. Uber/Lyft's commercial insurance – covers injuries and damages during active trips. 2. Another driver's insurance – if a third party caused the crash. 3. The Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Program (MVAC) – if the at-fault driver was uninsured or fled the scene. This means passengers are protected even if the rideshare driver has no personal coverage or if fault is unclear.

Common Scenarios and Who Pays

Scenario 1: Another driver causes the crash. That driver's insurance pays first. Uber/Lyft's commercial insurer covers any shortfall. Scenario 2: The rideshare driver causes the crash. Uber/Lyft's commercial policy pays for passenger injuries and property damage. Scenario 3: The driver was offline (app off). Only the driver's personal auto insurer applies. If uninsured, MVAC may provide limited compensation. Scenario 4: Both drivers share fault. Insurers apportion liability based on comparative negligence.

Why Suing Uber or Lyft Directly Is Difficult

Uber and Lyft structure their business models to limit corporate liability. Common legal obstacles include: Independent-contractor defence – Drivers aren't employees, so their negligence doesn't automatically attach to the company. Insurance shield – Their commercial insurer covers almost all injury claims. Strong legal defences – Uber and Lyft vigorously contest direct lawsuits. While these challenges make direct lawsuits rare, they don't affect your right to full compensation through insurance. A skilled lawyer ensures you're paid fairly — regardless of who technically holds liability.

Compensation Available for Rideshare Passengers

Injured Uber and Lyft passengers may claim compensation for: medical and rehabilitation expenses; pain and suffering; lost income and future earning capacity; psychological trauma (PTSD, anxiety); future care or mobility aids; property damage (phones, laptops, clothing). Depending on injuries and fault, Alberta rideshare passenger claims often settle between $75,000 and $500,000+.

Unsure whether to sue Uber, Lyft, or the driver?

Book Free consultation.

Steps to Take After an Uber or Lyft Accident

Following these steps immediately after an accident can significantly strengthen your case and protect your rights to compensation.

Call 911 and Ensure Police Attend

Ensure police attend the scene to document the accident properly.

Take Screenshots of Trip Details

Capture the driver's name, trip timestamp, and all app information before it's lost.

Photograph the Vehicles and Scene

Take photos of the vehicles, damage, and surrounding area for evidence.

Get Driver and Witness Contact Information

Collect contact details from the driver and any witnesses.

Report the Crash Through the App

Report the accident through the Uber or Lyft app immediately.

Request the Police Report Number

Obtain the police report number for your records.

Avoid Speaking With Insurers Before Consulting a Lawyer

Don't give recorded statements until you've consulted with legal counsel.

Contact an Alberta Rideshare-Accident Lawyer Promptly

App data can be lost within days. A lawyer can retrieve trip data and ensure your claim is filed correctly.

How a Lawyer Protects Passenger Rights

Even when direct lawsuits aren't required, legal representation is essential to ensure you receive full compensation and navigate the complex rideshare insurance system.

Identify All Available Insurance Coverage

Determining commercial, third-party, or MVAC coverage options.

Obtain Uber/Lyft Trip Data

Confirming app activity and trip status at the time of the crash.

Coordinate Medical and Rehabilitation Benefits

Ensuring you receive all available medical coverage and treatment.

Negotiate With Multiple Insurers

Preventing underpayment by coordinating with all involved insurance companies.

Pursue Litigation if Coverage Is Delayed or Denied

Taking legal action when insurers fail to provide fair compensation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

While Uber and Lyft rarely face direct lawsuits, passengers in Alberta are fully protected through commercial insurance. The key is proving that the driver was logged into the app and the trip was active when the crash occurred. If you've been injured in a rideshare accident: save trip screenshots and contact information; avoid insurer statements; seek legal advice early; let an experienced lawyer coordinate your claim. With skilled representation, you can recover compensation from the right insurer — and pursue Uber or Lyft directly if corporate negligence contributed to your injuries.

•

Passengers are protected through commercial insurance during active trips.

•

Direct lawsuits against rideshare companies are rare and require corporate negligence.

•

Multiple insurance sources may apply depending on fault and trip status.

•

A lawyer ensures you navigate the complex rideshare insurance system effectively.

Still have questions?

BOOK FREE CONSULTATION Call 403-527-7736