Legal Guide

Can an Insurer Refuse to Pay for Accidental Death?

Accidental-death insurance offers extra security and a higher payout for unexpected tragedies. Families expect quick payment for deaths due to crashes, falls, or other unforeseen events.

But Alberta insurers frequently refuse to pay accidental-death benefits, often claiming the death wasn't truly "accidental" or that an exclusion applies. These denials are frustrating and unfair — especially for those who paid premiums for years believing they were protected.

As Alberta insurance lawyers who previously defended insurers, we know how companies define "accident," the loopholes they exploit, and effective ways to challenge these denials.

This article explains what accidental-death coverage includes, common reasons for insurer denial, and actions families can take when claims are refused.

This guide covers:

What accidental-death insurance covers

Common reasons insurers deny claims

How Alberta courts interpret accidental-death claims

Legal defenses families can use

Steps to challenge a denial

When denials become bad faith

What Is an Accidental-Death Claim?

Accidental-death insurance (often referred to as "AD&D" for Accidental Death & Dismemberment) provides an additional payout when the insured dies or is severely injured as a direct result of an accident.

Three Main Sources of Coverage:

Group Accidental-Death InsuranceOffered through employers or professional associations. Usually supplements a basic life-insurance benefit.

Individual AD&D PoliciesPurchased privately for extra protection. May have strict definitions of "accident" and broad exclusions.

Accidental-Death RidersAdded to a life-insurance policy for an extra premium. Doubles the benefit if death is proven accidental.

Common Insurance Challenges in Alberta

Even clear-cut accidents can trigger disputes. Insurers frequently deny claims by arguing that:

The death wasn't "purely accidental"

Insurers may claim that contributing factors make the death non-accidental.

Contributing medical conditions caused or worsened the event

Pre-existing conditions are often used to deny coverage, even when they played no role.

The insured's actions were reckless or intentional

Insurers may argue that risky behavior negates accidental coverage.

An exclusion applies

Exclusions for intoxication, drug use, or criminal activity are often overused.

The cause of death was unclear or classified as "natural causes"

In elderly or medically complex cases, insurers default to 'natural causes' without thorough investigation.

Key point: While these justifications sound technical, Alberta law requires insurers to interpret ambiguity in favour of the insured — not themselves.

What Counts as an 'Accident' in Life-Insurance Law

There's no single legal definition of 'accident,' so courts interpret the term based on reasonable expectations. A death is considered accidental if: it results from an external, violent, and unforeseen event; the outcome was unintended and unexpected; the cause is independent of disease or natural causes. If the insured couldn't reasonably foresee the fatal result, the death is usually deemed accidental — even if secondary factors were present.

Motor-vehicle crashes

Covered as accidental deaths.

Falls or workplace injuries

Covered as accidental deaths.

Drownings

Covered as accidental deaths.

Carbon-monoxide poisoning

Covered as accidental deaths.

Electrocution

Covered as accidental deaths.

Fatal reactions to prescribed medication

Covered as accidental deaths.

When Insurers Wrongly Refuse Payment

Insurers often stretch definitions and exclusions to avoid paying accidental-death benefits. Common tactics include: blaming pre-existing conditions (even if they played no role); labeling deaths as 'natural causes' without investigation; applying behavioral exclusions overused; misclassifying suicides or overdoses; administrative or policy errors.

Common Exclusions in Accidental-Death Policies

Typical exclusions include: suicide (within two years); death while committing a criminal act; war, terrorism, or riot involvement; drug or alcohol impairment; illness, disease, or infection; intentional self-injury; participation in hazardous activities (e.g., skydiving, racing). If the exclusion isn't clearly worded or disclosed, Alberta courts may invalidate it.

How Alberta Courts Interpret Accidental-Death Claims

Alberta courts focus on foreseeability and intention. If the insured did not intend or reasonably expect death, it's considered accidental — even if risky behaviour was involved. Key Principles: 1. Intent matters — Courts distinguish between intentional self-harm and unintentional risk-taking. 2. Ambiguity favours the insured — If policy wording is unclear, the insurer loses. 3. Causation must be direct — The accident must primarily cause the death, but minor health issues don't automatically disqualify coverage. 4. Reasonable interpretation — Courts interpret 'accident' from the perspective of an ordinary person, not an insurer's technical definition.

When an Accidental-Death Denial Becomes Bad Faith

Insurers act in bad faith when they unreasonably delay, deny, or misrepresent coverage. Examples include: failing to investigate properly; relying on incomplete or biased medical opinions; ignoring conflicting evidence of accident; misstating the policy's definition of 'accident.' In Alberta, courts can award punitive damages to punish and deter such conduct — in addition to the death benefit itself.

Alberta-Specific Legal Protections

Insurance Act (RSA 2000, c I-3): Insurers must prove exclusions apply. Burden of Proof: The insurer bears responsibility for showing the death was excluded. Ambiguity Rule: Any unclear policy wording is interpreted for the insured. Bad-Faith Liability: Unreasonable denial or delay can attract additional damages. Limitation Period: Families must commence legal action within two years of denial.

Evidence That Strengthens Your Case

Full policy and application documents; death certificate and autopsy report; medical and toxicology records; police, accident, or EMS reports; witness statements or photographs; correspondence showing insurer delay or miscommunication. A lawyer organizes these records to prove the death was accidental and that exclusions were misapplied or invalid.

Was your accidental-death claim denied?

How to Challenge an Accidental-Death Denial

Following these steps can help families successfully challenge wrongful denials and secure the benefits they're owed.

Request Written Reasons

Demand a formal denial letter citing policy clauses and evidence used.

Obtain the Full Policy and Claim File

You're entitled to the complete contract, application, investigation notes, and all communications.

Review Medical and Forensic Records

Hospital, autopsy, and police reports often show the death was accidental or that exclusions were misapplied.

Gather Witness Statements

Eyewitness or family testimony can confirm intent, sobriety, or circumstances.

Contact an Alberta Insurance Lawyer

We can identify weak insurer arguments, coordinate expert reviews, and compel payment or settlement.

How a Lawyer Can Help

We can review your denial and policy wording, obtain all investigative records from the insurer, coordinate independent forensic or medical reviews, and negotiate full payment or pursue legal action under Alberta's Insurance Act. Most cases resolve through negotiation once insurers see that the claim will stand up in court. Need help reviewing your policy or denial letter? We can assess it for free.

Review Your Denial and Policy

Analyzing policy wording and denial reasons to identify weaknesses.

Obtain Investigative Records

Securing all documents and communications from the insurer.

Coordinate Expert Reviews

Working with forensic and medical experts to strengthen your case.

Negotiate or Pursue Legal Action

Pursuing full payment through negotiation or court action under Alberta's Insurance Act.

Legal Defenses Families Can Use

Lack of Intent: If there's no proof the insured intended death, the claim should be paid. Ambiguous Policy Language: Unclear definitions are interpreted in favour of the insured. Mental Capacity: If judgment was impaired by a medical condition, intent is negated. Causation Disputes: If disease didn't directly cause death, exclusions can't apply. Bad-Faith Conduct: Courts can impose aggravated or punitive damages for unreasonable denials.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

Accidental-death benefits are meant to protect families from financial hardship after a sudden loss — not to give insurers an escape clause. If your family's claim for accidental-death benefits has been denied, you don't have to accept the insurer's explanation. With proper evidence and legal representation, you can enforce your loved one's coverage and secure the compensation they intended for you.

•

Accidental-death exclusions must be proven, not assumed.

•

Ambiguities in policy wording are interpreted in your favour.

•

Medical complexity or minor health issues don't void coverage.

•

Alberta law gives you strong rights against unfair or bad-faith denials.

Denied AD&D benefits?

We can help you recover the compensation your family is owed. Call or text us today for a free consultation. No fee unless we win.

BOOK FREE CONSULTATION Call 403-527-7736