Can Aftermarket Parts Affect Motorcycle Liability in Alberta?
Many Alberta riders customize their motorcycles — adding aftermarket exhausts, custom lighting, performance brakes, or modified suspension systems. These upgrades are part of the culture, allowing riders to enhance performance, sound, or appearance.
But what happens if you're in an accident? Can aftermarket modifications affect your liability, insurance coverage, or injury claim?
In Alberta, the short answer is: it depends. Most modifications are legal and harmless. However, if an aftermarket part directly contributes to a collision or worsens an injury, it can impact both your claim and how insurers assess fault.
As Alberta motorcycle accident lawyers, we've seen cases where improper or unapproved modifications complicated otherwise straightforward claims. This guide explains:
This guide covers:
What Are Aftermarket Motorcycle Parts?
Aftermarket parts are components not made or approved by the motorcycle's original manufacturer. They can include aesthetic, performance, or structural modifications.
Common Examples of Aftermarket Mods in Alberta:
How Aftermarket Parts Can Affect Liability
Aftermarket modifications can impact your liability and compensation in several ways:
If the Modification Contributed to the Crash
Investigators and insurance companies analyze all contributing factors. If a modification caused or worsened the accident, it impacts liability. Examples include: an altered throttle or fuel controller causing unintended acceleration; non-standard tires reducing traction in wet weather; custom lighting making signals unclear to other drivers. If an aftermarket part caused unpredictable handling, insurers might argue for shared fault, even if another driver initiated the crash. Alberta follows comparative negligence, meaning your compensation can be reduced by your proven share of fault.
If the Modification Violated Safety Standards
Under Alberta's Vehicle Equipment Regulation (AR 122/2009), all motorcycles must meet specific safety and noise standards. Common violations include: exhaust systems exceeding permitted decibel limits; headlight or turn signal replacements not meeting visibility requirements; removing mirrors or fenders. If a modification breaches these regulations and contributes to a crash (e.g., a non-compliant headlight reducing visibility), it could lead to a reduction in the claim.
If the Modification Affects Insurance Coverage
Many insurance policies require that any performance or structural modifications be disclosed. If you install major aftermarket parts and fail to inform your insurer, they may: deny coverage if the modification caused or worsened the accident; reduce payouts if the bike's declared value doesn't match its modified value; void certain coverages, especially comprehensive or collision coverage. However, insurers cannot deny your injury claim (Section B or tort compensation) simply because your motorcycle was modified — unless the modification directly caused the crash.
If the Modification Worsens Injuries
Some modifications can increase injury risk — such as removing protective fairings, crash bars, or mirrors. If it can be proven that an aftermarket change worsened your injuries, insurers may argue contributory negligence, potentially reducing your settlement by a small percentage. Examples include: a custom seat or handlebar setup that limits control during emergency maneuvers; a removed windshield contributing to debris-related injuries. These arguments can often be challenged — but they highlight the importance of proper documentation and expert testimony in modified-bike cases.
Key point: While many modifications are perfectly legal, others may violate Alberta's equipment standards under the Traffic Safety Act, or void manufacturer safety certifications — which can matter when determining liability.
Steps to Take if You're in an Accident With a Modified Motorcycle
Following these steps immediately after an accident can significantly strengthen your case and protect your rights to compensation.
Call 911 and Report the Crash
Police should attend and document all vehicle conditions. Be honest about modifications if asked, but avoid speculating about fault.
Get Medical Attention
Even minor injuries require prompt medical documentation. This strengthens your claim and shows the accident's impact.
Document the Scene and Your Bike
Take photos of the accident scene, road conditions, damage, and any aftermarket parts. Evidence of proper installation and condition is crucial.
Keep All Maintenance and Modification Records
Service invoices or installation receipts prove professional work and compliance with standards.
Avoid Discussing Modifications With the Other Insurer
Insurers might use statements to shift blame. Speak only through a lawyer.
Consult an Alberta Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
Legal representation ensures modifications are accurately framed as neutral or safely installed features, not liabilities.
How a Lawyer Helps When Modifications Are Involved
Insurers sometimes use modifications as a default defense — claiming your bike was "unsafe" or "non-standard." In most cases, these arguments are weak and easily countered with proper evidence. Your lawyer can help by:
Investigating Fault
Gathering mechanical and forensic evidence to show the modification didn't contribute to the accident. Obtaining expert mechanical assessments showing the modification didn't cause or contribute to the crash.
Countering Insurer Bias
Challenging assumptions that custom bikes are automatically riskier. Gathering maintenance and service records proving the bike was in good condition.
Ensuring Compliance Evidence
Proving your modifications meet Transport Canada or provincial safety standards. Demonstrating driver negligence (e.g., the other motorist was texting, speeding, or failed to yield).
Maximizing Compensation
Including the value of damaged aftermarket parts in your property claim.
Handling Expert Reports
Working with mechanics or accident reconstructionists to strengthen your position.
Frequently Asked Questions
Conclusion
Aftermarket motorcycle parts are a normal part of riding culture in Alberta — they don't automatically increase your liability. However, improper or undeclared modifications can affect insurance coverage or fault assessments if they play a role in a crash. Aftermarket modifications often increase both repair costs and replacement value, while the rider's injuries and recovery costs can be significant. Common expenses include: medical and rehabilitation costs; lost wages and future income loss; physiotherapy or counseling for trauma; custom motorcycle repair or replacement; replacement of damaged aftermarket parts or gear. A fair settlement should reflect the full scope of losses — both personal and property-related — not reduced because of lawful customization.
Custom parts are legal if they meet Alberta's safety standards.
Insurers must prove a modification caused or worsened the accident to reduce compensation.
Proper documentation and disclosure protect your rights.
A lawyer ensures modifications don't become a barrier to fair recovery.
Injured in a motorcycle accident involving aftermarket parts?
Contact us today for a free consultation. No fee unless we win.